Song meaning of Grandma’s Boyfriend Paul by John Mulaney

The song "Grandma's Boyfriend Paul" by John Mulaney tells the story of a grandmother who has found a new romantic partner named Paul. The lyrics explore the reactions of the family members, particularly the narrator's aunts, who do not trust Paul or like him. However, the narrator himself supports their relationship and believes Paul is a good person. The song emphasizes the idea that love can be found at any age, and that judgment and prejudice should not stand in the way of someone's happiness.

The lyrics shed light on the common tendency for family members to be resistant to change, especially in matters of relationships and companionship for their loved ones. The narrator questions why everyone hates Paul, highlighting that he has not done anything wrong and does not deserve the negativity directed towards him. Instead, Paul is portrayed as being kind and gentle, engaging in harmless activities like reading mysteries. The song also touches on Paul's past experiences, such as serving in World War II, which adds depth to his character and displays his resilience.

Furthermore, the lyrics depict the tension and conflicts that arise within the family due to disagreements about sentimental objects, like a brooch that Grandma wore to a family event. The narrator recognizes that his mother and aunts are fixated on the brooch, even though it is unrelated to Paul's presence and should not be a cause for strife.

In the end, the narrator directly addresses his mother, expressing understanding for her loss and missing his grandfather but reminding her that Paul is not to blame for his absence. The lyrics suggest that it is important to let go of grudges, embrace the present, and not let prejudices dictate one's judgement of others.

Overall, "Grandma's Boyfriend Paul" delivers a powerful message of acceptance, love, and the need to challenge negative perceptions. It encourages listeners to prioritize the happiness of their loved ones and open their hearts to new relationships, regardless of age or societal expectations.