Song meaning of If I Loved You by Team StarKid (Ft. Joey Richter & Mariah Rose Faith)

The song "If I Loved You" by Team StarKid featuring Joey Richter and Mariah Rose Faith explores a complicated relationship dynamic between two characters, Pete and Steph. The lyrics suggest a power struggle and manipulation within the relationship.

Pete portrays himself as the victim, proclaiming that he never wanted Steph anyway and that she played a game by seducing him. He distances himself from the situation, claiming to be "off that train," implying he no longer wants to be involved.

Steph, on the other hand, challenges Pete's perspective. She questions his actions, stating that he is not off the hook and suggesting that he has been sending mixed signals. Steph asserts her self-worth and independence by rejecting the idea of being with a "geek" who would spend prom in a stall.

Throughout the song, both Pete and Steph express their hypothetical feelings if they were to love each other. They acknowledge the potential for love but question if it would be reciprocated or shown appropriately. They also highlight their own capabilities of loving someone, hinting at a desire for a deeper connection.

The second half of the song brings attention to the hidden motives and manipulative behaviors of both characters. They accuse each other of using power and manipulating the relationship for personal gain.

Overall, the song portrays a complex and dysfunctional relationship, highlighting themes of power dynamics, manipulation, and self-discovery. It suggests that love, if present, needs to be expressed and reciprocated authentically.