Song meaning of Black Diamond by The Replacements

The song "Black Diamond" by The Replacements seems to convey a message about being trapped or controlled by external forces. The lyrics highlight the struggle of living on the streets and feeling like one's life is just beginning, but being constantly under someone else's control. The repetition of the phrase "Out on the street for a living" emphasizes the difficult circumstances faced by the protagonist.

The mention of being under someone's thumb suggests a sense of oppression or manipulation. It signifies a lack of freedom and autonomy in one's life. The line "Doing everything I can, babe" implies a struggle to break free from this control but ultimately feeling unsuccessful. 

The chorus, with its repetition of "Ooh, black diamond," adds a sense of longing or desire for something more. The black diamond can be seen as a symbol of hidden potential or value that is not fully realized due to the constraints imposed by others.

In the second verse, the mention of a country and dreams implies that the struggle extends beyond just the streets, suggesting a broader social or political context. It speaks to the idea that even in a different setting, people are still marching and being controlled.

Overall, the song's lyrics depict a bleak and oppressive situation where individuals find themselves trapped and controlled by external forces. It sheds light on the struggle for autonomy and the desire to break free from the oppressive powers that hold us back.